Stocks are great to know about, yes, but even BETTER would be basic financial management. Who gets right out of high school and starts investing before landing their first job/credit card/own apartment? I know people do it, I just don’t see the logic (although I’d admit it does seem more fun).
Check out this comment by girlwithredballoon on an older post of mine:
“You know, I took Personal Finance in high school, but they didn’t teach anything about credit cards, compounding interest, different types of student loans – none of that! They taught us how to write checks, and then we had to play a stock market game where we chose companies to invest in. I know investing is important but knowing the dangers of credit cards ahead of time may have helped me to avoid them in college!”
Exactly! I learned how to write checks and balance a checkbook in Senior year too, but that was about it. There was no mention of 401k, IRAs (were they around in the 90’s?), credit cards, or just plain saving. But of course we had to play those stock investing games! God forbid we leave school without doubling up our FAKE money.
Maybe I’m naive, but I just don’t see how investing in individual stocks should come before the main pillars of personal finance. Think about it. Say a student triples his/her money in the “fake” market and then thinks he/she can make it big in real life and tries to out game it all? The odds are against them, especially if they think they can do it again in the 3-4 months allotted like in class. They then lose a chunk of their money and end up walking away thinking investing isn’t for them.
Only INVESTING isn’t about just individual stocks! It can be a main ingredient, but there’s plenty of other places you can put your money – CDs, bonds, mutual funds, target-date funds, treasury bills, etc etc. Stocks can do wonders for your portfolio (I love ’em to death!) but you should have a grasp on the rest of the areas before jumping in and playing.
You teach a kid how to save 10% of all their income, or pay their debt off on-time, and it’s a whole new ball game! Not as fun to teach I’m sure, but it’ll stick with them MUCH longer than some crazy stock game. Am I right? Am I missing something here?
Jay loves talking about money, collecting coins, blasting hip-hop, and hanging out with his three beautiful boys. You can check out all of his online projects at jmoney.biz. Thanks for reading the blog!